Showing posts with label same-sex marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label same-sex marriage. Show all posts

Sunday, March 31, 2013

What the Redefinition of Marriage in France and the United States Says about Our Cultural and Political Differences (and what it does not).


In our ongoing quest for better understanding the cultural differences between France and the United States, the issue of same-sex marriage (or Marriage for All as it is called in France) is a case in point as it has been in the headlines in both our countries this week. It makes for an interesting pause.

In the United States, the talk is mostly about legal rights and equality, when in France, it's been mostly about families and children.This of course stems from significant differences in cultural, legal and political contexts. In the U.S. the battles for equality and civil rights are typically fought in court (up to the Supreme Court) rather than through the legislative process as in France.

This week the U.S. Supreme Court heard two cases:
- one concerns the constitutionality of California's ban on gay marriage (Called Prop 8)
- the other is a challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act (or DOMA) passed by the U.S. Congress in 1996  which prevents the recognition of same-sex marriage at the federal level, even when recognized by individual states.


In France, a bill granting French same-sex couples (better known as Marriage for All / Mariage pour Tous) the right to marry and jointly adopt children was recently voted by the National Assembly in February. It now needs to be approved by the Senate to become law. The vote is scheduled for April 4. So last week-end was sort of a last chance for the opponents to gather people and express their view... in the streets of Paris. And they did.

DIFFERENT POLITICAL CONTEXTS
And this yet another major difference between France and the U.S.: whereas Americans fight against what they deem as unjust laws in court before a judge; in France, they do so in the streets so as to put pressure on their political leaders, especially right before a vote in the House or the Senate. As a result, the impressive marches and counter-demonstrations need to be taken into cultural perspective. It is quite common in France.

In both our countries, the right-wing parties (The Republican Party in the U.S. and the UMP in France) are the parties of opposition to same-sex marriage. In the U.S., however, the Republicans are slowly changing their minds, including some of their leaders (NYTimes) but also major conservative pundits like Bill O'Reilly (see here). This is due to change in public opinion as polls show that supports for same-sex marriage even among American conservatives is growing. It is also the result of individual politicians changing their minds because they have relatives coming out, as is the case of Senator Portman. (here)


In France, the political context is very different as the left-wing government is down in the poll and under a lot of pressure because of a very gloomy economic environment. So the opposition is emboldened and seizes any political opportunity that can become a lightning rod for anger over President Francois Hollande’s economic policies:
Some demonstrators called for Hollande to resign, citing France’s deteriorating economy. “The protestors’ slogans have changed,” Le Parisien newspaper said. “They are no longer limited to the subject of marriage but are encroaching on economic matters.”(Bloomberg). 
The latest major protest last week drew between 300 000 (according to the authorities) and 1.4 million people (claimed by the organizers), ... and the the truth is probably in between, (say 600, 000). Of course, not all the protesters have done so for political reasons alone, but nonetheless, pretty much all of them were right-wing voters and/or catholic activists, including extremists for some of them.

FRENCH TEA PARTY?
Some commentators in France (here in French) have even seen similarities between the 'Demonstration for All' (as the anti-Marriage-for-All demonstrators have called themselves) and the Tea Party in the United States. The resemblance is indeed striking.

Both movements:
  • are made of white middle-class conservatives who can't keep up with change,
  • believe they defend the traditional values of the country,
  • claim to be non-political but to represent the "silent majority",
  • are against the "mainstream media" (who, they believe, have all an agenda)
  • have a lot of anger in them (and express it - read this article in French), and promise doom, including civil war, if they are not listened to (France-info)
  • use patriotic symbols (national flags), including founding mythical revolutionary symbols from the 18th century. (see pictures below)




  • are well organized, with codes,  colors (yellow / pink) and flags.
  • have chosen charismatic female voices (Sarah Palin / Frigide Barjot) as their leaders.
  • deny the legitimacy of the representative democracy

Of course, the comparison only goes so far - for one, the Manif Pour Tous movement is so far only focused on the same-sex marriage issue, and it is also tied to the catholic church who's been a very vocal opponent.

Despite these movements, it should be noticed that in both France and the U.S.polls show that a majority of people support same-sex marriage. (here France and here for the U.S.).

FRAMING THE ISSUE
As far as the issue is concerned in France, the opponents to Marriage-for-All framed it not in terms of equality, as you might have expected, but in terms of "family values", not only regarding adoption (which is in the bill) but also concerning the right for reproductive technology or gestational surrogacy (which are not in the bill). The latter is not only illegal in France for heterosexual couples, but it is also a very divisive issue. Hence the confusion.

As a result, the debate has not been about the rights of homosexuals to marry but about their rights to have a children (which tends to be more divisive). Eventually, this was shifted to the "rights of children" (i.e. to have both a father and a mother) as opposed to the rights of adults.
This semantic spin is very powerful: first because it seems like a legitimate question, then because it confuses people who are not very familiar with the issue and finally because the right of children is undeniably sacred. (Who can seriously be against children's rights?), and trumps over the right of adults.
But instead of focusing on the rights of children of gay couples, who already exist, they have turned the argument to the right of potential children who do not yet exist  (i.e. who may be born if the bill becomes law.)
By saying that a child needs both a father and a mother, they actually assume that single-sex parents are not good enough to raise children. This ironically fails to take into account the fact that, in France, it has been legal for at least 50 years for single people to adopt a child,without anyone making any fuss about it.
The magic word used for the right of children argument by all the opponents to the bill is "filiation" - not a very common word in English or French. It means "lineage" and is often used in legal discourse to determine the paternity of a child. (see this Le Monde Article).  It is a very powerful concept because it is linked to heritage - a concept central to French culture and identity. France even has a special day of celebration of its national heritage, called "Heritage Day" (Journée du Patrimoine) and the success of its grand Agricultural Fair in Paris is another expression of the French symbolic attachment to their roots.
This is clearly a cultural difference between France and the United States. This question of "filiation" is not something you'd hear in the American debate, even when the question of adoption is raised.

ADOPTION BY SAME-SEX COUPLES.
In fact, just last week, Justice Antonin Scalia, a very conservative Supreme Court Justice also linked the
redefinition of marriage to the question of adoption, he said :
And there is considerable disagreement among sociologists as to what the consequences of raising a child in a single-sex family, whether that os harmful to the child, or not. (Wash. Post)
As Jon Stewart reminded us, his claim is contradicted by serious studies, including those done by the American Academy of Pediatrics who say
There is no cause-and-effect relationship between parents' sexual orientation and children's well being". 
Here's also what the American Sociological Association reports:
The claim that same-sex parents produce less positive child outcomes than opposite-sex parents—either because such families lack both a male and female parent or because both parents are not the biological parents of their children—contradicts abundant social science research. Decades of methodologically sound social science research, especially multiple nationally representative studies and the expert evidence introduced in the district courts below, confirm that positive child wellbeing is the product of stability in the relationship between the two parents, stability in the relationship between the parents and child, and greater parental socioeconomic resources. Whether a child is raised by same-sex or opposite-sex parents has no bearing on a child’s wellbeing. (Read here, p.3)
Clearly, if the standard for recognizing marriage is whether or not the couple would make good parents, a lot of heterosexuals should not marry.

Stewart of course says it way better:


Of course the 'filiation problem' is just a smoke screen which has no bearing on reality. It is a lot of hot hair that's been well crafted so as to seem to be part of the widely shared national cultural values. The tactic is clearly to confuse and scare people. In this respect, it is not so different from the tactics of the Tea Party movement.
What it comes down to is the belief that homosexuals cannot be proper parents. It is nothing new even if the packaging is different. It is rooted in the old idea that homosexuality is morally wrong, even a a perversion and that it will pervert innocent children.

As for the argument of "tradition", which denounces the change in the law on the ground of tradition,  it is precisely that tradition that saw homosexuality as a legally intolerable perversion. The use of tradition in this respect is indicative of a very poor understanding of history. Clearly, just like the civil union 10 years ago, it will soon be a non-issue. But in the meantime, it is painful to watch so much anger and intolerance.

Whereas the decision of the Supreme Court remains to be seen, and won't be made before June, it is likely that the French Senate will vote the law on April 4 anyway. So why the big fuss? What do the anti-Marriage-for-All people want?

THE REFERENDUM QUESTION
Well, they say they want a referendum, which seems like a good democratic principle since it lets the entire nation decide, but in fact it is a very dangerous populist argument.
  • First, because referendums in France have always been not about the question asked, but about whether or not you support the government. 
  • Second, because article 11 of the Constitution (ironically passed by the conservative Sarkozy majority) specifies that it is impossible to have a referendum on questions concerning the civil society (See here in French)
  • Thirdly, and more importantly, because you don't put a fundamental right to a vote precisely precisely because of the risk of the majority tyrannizing the minority. That's the whole idea of fundamental civil rights and this is a civil rights issue (see my post here) It's like asking white people whether blacks could marry whites in the American South in the 60s. Being gay is no different in the sense that it is part of who you are and not something you can change. As such, it is a civil rights issue, not a simple political issue. 
BIGOTRY BUT HOPE TOO.
Lastly, and despite everything I have said here, and my attempts at understanding this movement, I still fail to see why people get so worked up about a law that would not affect their lives in the least and is simply an extension of their own existing rights. In this case, giving more rights  to others does not take anything away from anyone else. And those people call themselves Christian? Where exactly does their action fit anything Jesus ever said?
At the risk of being politically incorrect, the arguments used by people opposing same-sex marriage are steeped in bigotry, and there's no other way around it. And this is true both in France and the United States. Our bigots may look and sound different, but deep down, they are very similar.

Bigotry is the result of ignorance and a lack of basic empathy. The very fact that people who have relatives that come out gay change their minds - think of Dick Cheney for instance - is very telling. Once people put a human face to homosexuality, they become more accepting. They don't define them by their sexual orientation. They see them as real people with the same basic needs, faults and qualities who just happen to have a different sexual orientation. So once more homosexuals come out, people will realize that they are in every circle, and they will become more tolerant and less judgmental.
So there is hope of light of the end of tunnel. We can already see it! Alleluia!



Sunday, February 10, 2013

Same Sex Marriage Debate(s)?

It is quite rare that similar legislation are debated at about the same time on either side of the Channel, but this month, both the U.K. and France are about to make same-sex marriage legal.
On Feb. 12, the French National Assembly is expected to pass a measure legalizing same-sex marriage. Although the bill still needs to win the approval of the French Senate and be signed by the president, it is expected to become law as soon as May 2013.
On Feb. 5, the British House of Commons voted overwhelmingly in favor of a same-sex marriage measure. Another vote in the House of Commons and a vote in the House of Lords are still to come, but the bill is expected to pass and become law in summer 2013. (Pew Forum)
In both countries, the legislation has large public support (here and here).

WHAT ABOUT THE UNITED STATES THEN?
Nationwide, there is a now majority of public opinion in favor of it. But, as always with the U.S., most laws are defined by the states, rather than the federal government. So far, 9 states have legalized same-sex marriage - 3 of which through popular vote - but 30 states prohibit it in their constitutions.
At the federal level, The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), passed in 1996, prevents the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages and allows each state to refuse recognition of same-sex marriages performed in other states (Wikipedia).
Since then, a lot has happened: both Bill Clinton changed and Barrack Obama changed their minds a (here and here), and Obama became the first sitting president to endorse marriage rights for same-sex couples. As with other politicians, it seems that this change of mind can be attributed to personal ties, and to having gay people leading comfortably conventional lives in their worlds. Exposure is definitely a key factor in how people respond.
As often the case in major legal issues in the United States, it is now up to the Supreme Court to weigh in, notably about the constitutionality of DOMA. (NYTimes). It remains to be seen whether the justices have also had similar exposure as other politicians have. Their decision is expected in June.

In the meantime, it may be interesting to hear what happens elsewhere. As you can see in Jon Stewart's funny report here below, the debate and vote in the U.K. was relatively uncontroversial and swift (only 6 hours),  ending in a 400–175 vote in favor, including almost half of the the Tories (conservative).


FRENCH AND AMERICAN EXTREMISM
This is definitely not something you'll see in France and probably not in the U.S. either. Despite public support in these countries, the topic is also clearly more controversial and divisive for American and French politicians alike.
You may be surprised of the similarities of the arguments used by the most extreme conservatives in both France and the United States. As in the video above, similar outrageous homophobic have floated around linking homosexuality to polygamy, incest, pedophilia, and even zoophilia (The Guardian)

In a measure of the bitterness of the public debate, Serge Dassault, CEO of the Dassault industrial group and a conservative politician, predicted in November that gay marriage would lead to the decline of the French nation, like the peoples of ancient Greece.
"We'll have a country of gays and in 10 years there'll be nobody left - that's stupid," the senator for the centre-right UMP party said.
In September, Cardinal Philippe Barbarin, the Roman Catholic archbishop of Lyon, argued that plans to redefine the concept of marriage would open the door to incest and polygamy. (BBC)

RELIGION
Most surprisingly, in a country with such strict separation between church and state, religious leaders have been deeply involved and unanimously against the bill, even though the new law would only affect civil marriage, which are strictly distinct from religious ones. (In France, people who want to marry in the church have two ceremonies - one for the Republic, and one with a priest).
Yet, almost half of practicing catholics are in favor of it and even the right-wing Catholic review Temoignage Chretien (Christian Testimony) has endorsed this bill in an editorial, (published in Le Monde).:
The impact of its statement is even more interesting in that it comes from a religious publication:
"Homosexuality has been persecuted or oppressed for many centuries. However, it is a sexual orientation as legitimate and worthy as heterosexuality. Marriage is a contract chosen by people more freely and willingly today than ever. … Denying homosexuals that contract would add yet another layer of discrimination on those who have been too often subjected to such indignities. That's why we believe it is fair to open marriage to those who want to give a legal framework to strengthen their union.” (Translation here)
POLITICAL EXPEDIENCY
As in the U.S. this new bill was also a political opportunity for the conservative opposition to the government to rally its radical wing, especially after the deep division over the leadership of the party.
The French right (....) has attempted to draw out the proceedings for as long as possible. More than 5,300 amendments have been tabled by the opposition, some of which were absurdist, such as the demand that polygamous and incestuous marriages be legalised in the name of equal rights.
Several rightwing MPs warned of an influx of gay foreigners wanting to marry in France. With about 3,000 amendments still to be dealt with in at least another week of debate, the spats are continuing, with the speaker of parliament often urging both sides to calm down. (The Guardian)
Since the law would also allow gay couples to adopt, the conservatives have strategically focus the debate on "children", but not the children of the gay couples that exist, but of the potential children that might exist and be raised by gay families, claiming the "children need both a father and a mother", conveniently forgetting that single people have had the legal right to adopt since 1966. This was as smart as the support for adoption by gay couples barely reaches 50%.

That being said, there was there more to it than mere political expediency as for a lot of people who demonstrated against the bill, it was more about what it means to be a parent than about marriage. Then there is a fear for some people that it might lead to legalizing artificially induced pregnancies for gay couples, and surrogate motherhood which is seen by many in France as exploitation of poor working women by the rich (NYTimes) - something that goes against the founding myths of France.

FRENCH PHILOSOPHICAL DEBATE.
Because this is France, philosophy and intellectual debates play a greater role in shaping public opinion than in any other country.
In a brilliant Op-Ed in the International Herald Tribune, Robert Zaresky considers that at the heart of the matter is the meaning of the trio of revolutionary values — liberty, equality and fraternity — that France has made its own since 1789, illustrating the  question by the debate between two of France’s most influential intellectuals: Elisabeth Badinter and Sylviane Agacinski, who a fierce debate with similar argument about a law imposing sexual parity in political office.
At heart of it, is a disagreement  about attributing rights based on difference instead of sameness.
Basically, Badinter rejected political "parité" for the same reasons she favors same-sex marriage - the idea that revolutionary France’s liberating credo is based on the universal character of human rights, and the no one should be treated different based on race or gender.
Attributing rights based on difference instead of sameness would reduce the nation to a motley collection of tribes, each pursuing its own instead of the nation’s interest. France would become little better than America, where the range of hyphenated citizens would be as varied as the coffees at Starbucks.
For Agacinski, life’s fundamental dichotomy is the biological difference between a man and a woman, and the difference needs to be recognized so inequality can be remedied. This view also leads her to believe that "the family is yoked to biological filiation", which has been the argument of those opposing the bill.
The problem is that both claim their respective positions have universal foundations which may explain in part the radicalization of the debate.
Where Agacinski glimpses the end of civilization as we know it, Badinter sees civilization as we should know it. 
It seems to me that this EITHER/OR is a false dichotomy. There is room in the French republic for those who claim the "right to be different" (a popular motto of the 60s and 70s) and those who claim "the right to be the same".
There is more danger in denying differences; as Badinter does, because it threatens individual liberties to which all humans aspire.
That being said, I also fail to see the logical link between the fundamental different between a man and a woman, and biological filiation that Agacinski  makes. Research has shown that sexual identity is not synonymous with gender, and a child can develop his sexual identity, even when raised by same-sex parents. (notwithstanding that role models other than just the parents exist in any family).
In this respect, I agree with Badinter that desire, not biology, is essential. It is interesting that heterosexual desire for children tends to be praised, when the desires for homosexuals to have children is often seen as selfish. This reeks of homophobia.
The family, Badinter contends, is the “convergence of individual liberty and shared goals.” It is immaterial whether a couple’s child issues directly from the couple or a surrogate mother. If anything is sacred, it is not the womb, but a couple’s desire, whether they are infertile or gay, to raise a child.

I would like to end this on a note of irony in the words of Frederic Martel in another article by the NYTimes:
Now we’re at a moment when we are all a bit hysterical about marriage — gay marriage. But this is really a conservative movement, about stability in society and being good parents and protecting children and becoming rather ordinary.” (NYTimes)


Sunday, November 4, 2012

The Paradox of Today's Christianity.

One of the greatest paradoxes of today's Christianity is that of two topics that get Christians all worked up in America and increasingly in France (here) these days, namely abortion and same-sex marriage/homosexuality, neither is mentioned by Jesus Christ himself.
He said plenty, however, about love, helping the poor, or against wealthy possessions; his compassion extending to those excluded by society, not just the poor, but also women, children, lepers, prostitutes or tax collectors.
This paradox is all the greater that it is not as if our society had stopped excluding people and manufacturing poverty, and if nothing else, the current economic crisis is a good reminder that there is plenty to feel indignant about in our world other than homosexuality or abortion.
Condemnation of homosexuality, which is seen as a sin by most Christians, and abortion do not come out of thin air of course. On this day of worship, this seems like a good topic to discuss.

Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage :
There are very few references to homosexuality in the bible, but those that exist have been understood as strongly condemning it. But it is in fact slightly more complicated.

The Old Testament laws clearly condemn homosexuality (Levetivus 18:22) but they also condemn adultery, or brides that are not virgin (Deut. 22:13-21) or sexual intercourse for married couple during a woman's period (Lev. 18:19) to death (by stoning). Clearly, we do not live under the same laws.
As for the passage in Sodom and Gomorrah, from which sodomy comes, it is not about homosexuality, but against sexual immorality and perversion, and against gang rape (i.e. the rape of the angels sent to retrieve Lot).

As for the New Testament, there are very few references and those condemn not homosexual relationships but "lust" and "unnatural relations" (which some scholars understand as homosexual acts committed by heterosexuals, such as temple prostitution or pederasty, which were commonly practiced back then). Roman 1:26-27 for instance is consistent with Paul's condemnation of the worship of Pagan gods from earlier in the chapter.

Then there is the highly controversial question of variation in translation - anyone who has studied tow languages knows how difficult it is to translate a concept from one culture to another.
There are not words in Hebrew, Aramaic or Greek for "homosexual" or "homosexuality". There is debate among Greek scholars as to the meaning of arsenokoitai, which has been often translated as 'homosexuals' but is unusual. a word like malaokois which is often translated by "effeminate boy" becomes "male prostitute" in the New Revised Standard version (1 Corinthians 6:9 and 1 Timothy 1:10). (see here or here). This is all up to scholars, of course, but we should remember that there is controversy there at least.

Even if we don't want to bother getting into complicated theological and linguistic debates, what is clear is that what the bible condemns consistently is not sexual relationships but sexual behaviors that desecrate the body (the Temple of the Holy Spirit) such as prostitution, or religious and orgiastic sex. In other words, it condemns acts that objectify people and turn them into mere tools of pleasure, and thus deny their humanity. It is consistent with its general condemnation of "godless, wicked, idol worshippers." This is no more the case of homosexuals than it is the case of heterosexuals. Behavior and not sexual orientation is what the bible is about. Of course, 2000 years ago, there was no concept of 'sexual orientation', (Some even argue that David and Jonathan's friendship could have been more than just platonic). In any case, people dealt with what they knew then, just as we deal with what we know now.)

Finally, it seems enough to me that Jesus himself, who was constantly with 12 other men, never once mentioned homosexuality. Had it been a major issue, you'd think he would have made it pretty clear.

By opposing same-sex marriage, evangelical and catholic leaders have inverted christian values - if anything, they should support it fully as it provide more stability to homosexuals who are seeking to have a family.
As to the question of children, not only is there no evidence that being raised by homosexual couples has an impact at all, but it is a moot question since it is already the case of thousands of them. Should we not give them the legal safety net that other children have?

Abortion :
The Bible never mentions abortion even though there were common even then (herbal abortifacients such as pennyroyal and silphium were used among other 'methods' in Ancient Times, see here).  Interestingly, Exodus 21 distinguishes the killing of a "person" (punished by death) and the killing of a fetus (punished by fine). On the other hand, there are references that suggest that human life begins before birth (even if as to when is not specified) in Gen. 25:22, Luke 1:41 and Psalm 139:13.
If you start looking at pictures of fetus formation and read about it, you can easily see that of course it is a human being before birth. It is hard to tell when this begins, but let's say, for the the sake of argument, that it starts at conception. Believing that life is most important is something I subscribe to as a Christian and as such I should be against abortion. In theory I am, but in practice I am not.
I think this is an issue that needs a bit of reality check and a pragmatic approach, especially if we take life as utterly important. Because a fetus is in a woman's womb, there will always be a way for women who really want an abortion (and in certain cases, such as rape or incest, you can easily see why) to have one. It would be helpful to look at the consequences of making abortion illegal: it would a return to back alley abortions. Then the risk would be to lose not only the fetus, but the mother as well, especially because it would be an opportunity for unlicensed hacks to make a profit. It would also widen the gap between the poor and those who can afford to pay for medical assistance.
It seems to me that the consequences on life loss would be worse, if one is only to take life as a criteria. It seems like more logical to wish abortions be performed in safe environments where those women, often in desperate situations, can also be given alternatives (such as adoption) as well as counseling. In addition, it might be also as important to support sex education, including contraceptive methods, instead of "abstinence only" (see here).  Teaching kids about sex does not mean one encourages them to have sex, but as a teacher myself, I know that kids are greatly misinformed and knowledge never hurts.

These two issues have become the obsession of many Christian activists and church leaders. In France, one can deplore the lack of biblical culture, including among Catholics, and the highly hierarchical workings of the church. In the United States, the church is too often a social place where initial bias is re-enforced by people with similar culture, race and social backgrounds, where verses are learned like mantras and where bible study groups serve to re-inforce the dominant view. With a few notable exceptions, questioning the  consensus can be really hard and it is unfortunate that so often feel-goodism and self-righteousness prevail over genuine theological debates. There's hope, however, and I find comfort in reading Brian D. McLaren or Gregory Boyd, or this young gutsy minister, Ryan Bauers.


Thursday, November 1, 2012

Elections 2012: the Minnesota Referendum.

As the day of the presidential elections is nearing, the media in France have had all sorts of programs and special reports on american politics. What is often forgotten, however, is that besides the fight for the presidency, these are also major congressional  and local elections. In fact, there are myriads of other local issues that Americans will have to vote for or against. A lot of these issues are important because they both reflect and foretell what is at work in American society as a whole. 


This is the case of Minnesota where two important referendums are taking place this year. To understand what is at stake, we're going to give voice to a native of the North Star State who has been a contributor in the past and is well aware of what is at stake politically both nationally and locally :

Why I will vote NO in November

There are two important referendums on the ballot in Minnesota this November. The first is asking us whether we would like to see a law requiring Voter ID to prevent voter fraud. The second is asking us to vote on an amendment to the state constitution that would define marriage as the relationship between a man and a woman alone. I will be voting no on both these amendments.

The first referendum is actually quite simple for me. The voter fraud issue that the new law is supposed to address simply doesn’t exist. The only kind of voter fraud that Voter ID would address is impersonation fraud (someone trying to vote under a false name) and this type of fraud is virtually non-existent. Very few individuals are going to risk a felony for the sake of one vote. The burden of proof for this fraud is on the group proposing the change. I am unconvinced. On a general level, I am against writing new laws to address problems that don’t exist.

The second referendum deals with the definition of marriage, limiting its status to the union of a heterosexual couple. I have spoken with some very intelligent people who have a variety of opinions on this, from legal scholars to business owners, teachers, and stay-at-home parents. The bulk of arguments in favor of the amendment stem from three lines of reasoning: 1) let voters decide how to define marriage rather than activist judges, 2) marriage has always been a unique institution defined as a union between a man and a woman for the propagation of humanity and upbringing of children, and 3) we have to protect family values since the family unit is the core of a healthy society. Arguments against the amendment generally rest on appeals to civil rights.

On principle, I am reluctant to change the state constitution as a preventative measure. The state currently recognizes only heterosexual marriage in its statutes. The amendment will not change that. It is designed to prevent some future panel of judges from changing that. But again the law as it stands already recognizes marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman. An amendment would effectively freeze this definition for a much longer period. I think it imprudent to prevent my children from making their own decision on this issue. I recognize that opinion on this issue has evolved over time. I believe that they should have the opportunity, like we have, to make up their own minds on this issue. The first ten amendments to the federal constitution, the Bill of Rights, protect individual and group rights. This amendment seems to me starkly at odds with the spirit of those amendments.

Furthermore, my position stems from my experience as a teacher and a traveler. As a traveler I have lived in other countries that allow gays to marry and I see little difference between their values and ours. The gays I know in the US, France, Belgium and Canada bear little resemblance to the caricatures I see in the press or in breathless stories of gay activism. They are, to a person, normal people living out their daily existence at work and at home. My gay colleagues at school, from my time as a student and as a professor, have been lovely people with a great capacity for kindness and friendship. I have never felt offended or threatened by their sexual orientation. On the contrary, I have found them to be professional, discreet, and exceedingly normal.

I grew up in a conservative community. My brother was one of four black children in a Midwestern town of 5,000. I have witnessed what happens to the outlier in a small community. Subcultures are a way for mainstream culture to categorize deviant behaviors (punk, gay, black, stoner, etc.). I am a professor whose work deals with personal and collective identity. I ask my students to recount an important experience in their life. Invariably a few students write about the moment they realized they were gay or, just as often, the day they came out. Each story is fraught with angst and full of inspiration as the individuals come to accept/embrace this part of their identity and, more often than not, discover a true friend who listens and loves them just as they are. Our society has gone to great lengths to demonize gays. I still remember in high school hearing about gay bashing from Christians. I regret not standing up for the victims in the face of such obvious stupidity.

And finally, I have no patience for the politics of stereotypes. Generalizations are the bane of our society. People that have never met a gay person generalize from the five percent of gays they see in the press, movies and TV shows. From this limited encounter we get: “Gays are flamboyant activists with an agenda that will ruin our country.” But one could also generalize about conservative Christians in our country and frequently we do. Some people look at the Westboro Church picketing the funerals of soldiers and draw the conclusion that all conservative Christians are ignorant, judgmental and offensive. Having made friends in both communities, I have found the reality to be quite the opposite. Most Christians and gays that I know are kind, hard-working people with no agenda beyond their basic survival in this world, an existence so ordinary as to be almost banal. They find meaning in their existence through their work, families, friends, spirituality and hobbies. The hate-filled Christian and the activist gay are far from the norm in my experience, despite what we hear from the press. These two groups are simply full of people trying to find their way in this world, a experience I can appreciate. As for gays ruining the fabric of our society, I think we Christians have managed to do that on our own just fine.

So I will be voting no on the marriage amendment because a) it changes nothing, b) I think it leaves a poor legacy for our children, and c) it is based on a series of generalized stereotypes that are foreign to my own experience. I respect the right of others to disagree. I rarely voice my politic opinion so publicly, but I very much disagree not only with these two amendments but the politics behind them. And in the case of the marriage amendment, I felt it my responsibility to do what I failed to do so many years ago, to speak up.
                                                                                                                                           D.L.
NOTE from editor: Just a few words on the same-sex marriage referendum. . The idea that "voters decide how to define marriage rather than activist judges" is a very popular argument that speaks to most people because it sounds very democratic.
This may be misleading though :  if you consider same-sex marriage is a 'civil right' issue, then it's like putting a fundamental right to vote with the risk of the majority tyrannizing the minority (Imaging asking the South whether they should allow blacks to vote in the 60s). As Barbara Gamble says in her article, Putting Civil Rights to a Popular Vote, in the American Journal of Political Science o
"Without the filtering mechanisms of the representative system, direct democracy promotes majority tyranny as the scope of civil rights conflicts expands and citizens vote on civil rights laws."
Barbara Gamble, Putting Civil Rights to a Popular Vote, in the American Journal of Political Science, Vol. 41, No. 1, Jan., 1997  (here)
Now I know this may seem a bit far fetched to a lot of heterosexuals that gay marriage should be a civil right issue in the first place, but it depends how you look at homosexuality. And this is where words and definitions are crucial on our understanding of the issue :
Terms like"lifestyle", or "sexual preference" which are often used imply a choice and frame the issue in a way that is different from the reality of most homosexuals - most gays do not feel they have a choice (and given the crap they're given by society, one can assume that if they had a choice, they would make a different one). Whether it is genetics or psychological (or both) does not really matter if they feel they can't change their sexual orientation anyway. Therefore, it is like skin color. It is part of who they are.
Now the question of whether marriage is a right has long been established in the American legal system - it was made very clear during the civil rights movement of the 60s with regard to interracial marriage. (which really re-enforces my point)
See the 14th Amendment to the Constitution
"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."
The U.S. Supreme Court first applied this to marriage in Loving v. Virginia (1967), where it struck down a Virginia law banning interracial marriage.
This seems to me a very logical argument to make against asking voters about same-sex marriage, but it is not something I often read. It seems like the populist argument that the majority is always right has prevailed, but the framers made it very clear in the Constitution that certain rights are inalienable, even by the majority. It all comes down of course to how you see homosexuality: is it a choice or not? The best way to find the answer is to ask the homosexuals you may know.

UPDATE from editor: It turns out that both initiatives in Minnesota were defeated :
Minnesota voters turned back two constitutional amendments Tuesday, defeating proposals to ban gay marriage and require a photo ID for voting that had once been seen as likely winners. (here)